Bill Carroll

10

Young sauternes nose, fresh lemon peel, finessed, great structure, flint. Drank at Le Charme de Pit, Athens, Greece — 6 years ago

Bill Carroll

9.1

Decanted for 3 hours. Barn floor, rustic raspberries, cow hide, smoke. Acid is balanced but solid funk. Great steal for $40 — 8 years ago

Bill Carroll

9.1

Very light red, big smoked meats. Brisket sandwich — 8 years ago

Bill Carroll

10

Opened 2+ hours in a decanter. Sweet leather, tobacco. Cherry skin, ripe black cherry, rustic orange peel. Brown and orange secondary colors mesh perfectly with the settled red center. Great age. Medium bodied. Lovely elegance. Applewood smoked bacon. Acidity has relaxed over time. Drinking really well. — 7 years ago

with Randall

Bill Carroll

8.0

Basement find... lean kabinett that wants so bad to be an auslese — 8 years ago

Bill Carroll

9.8

Bill had this 8 years ago

Bill Carroll

9.0

"Roses, rotten fruit, dead leaf"-Peter, Income Tax — 7 years ago

with Nelson

Bill Carroll

8.9

Bill had this 8 years ago

Bill Carroll

9.0

2014 — 8 years ago

Bill Carroll

9.6

Bill had this 8 years ago