12/25 - great ruby color out of the bottle. Well made and balanced. Very solid Can 88 — 3 months ago
12/25 think the wine has a good measure of cab franc and it was evident in a good way. Nice balance with dark fruit and plenty of earth. Well made and Rosenthal like the traditional winemaking process. Needs time. 88 — 3 months ago
2/26 beautiful bottle. Soft with lots of earth and power. 90 — 11 days ago
2/26 89 — a month ago
12/25 wine was nicely resolved after 15 years. Big, rich, dark wine. 89 — 3 months ago
12/25 an old Cabernet. 31 years old. Plenty of funk with a dark quality. 84 — 3 months ago
2/26 - amazing qualities all around. A fruit driven wine with lots or red plum and darker blackberry notes. Nice cedar and tobacco notes. Firm tanins. Outstanding mouthfeel. Soft finish. 93 — a month ago
12/25 - nice wine. Toro’s have most Grenache and Carignan. Dark mineral driven grapes and other grapes like Cab are often added. 88. — 3 months ago
12/25 - light weight Barolo. Unremarkable 83 — 3 months ago
Lawrence Bernstein
1/26 lovely old Bordeaux. Soft, aged but it still had good structure and fruit. 88 — 4 days ago