Matt Cory 
Jean et Sébastien Dauvissat
Montmains Chablis 1er Cru Chardonnay 2010
Matt had this 10 years ago
Arco del Reloj
No. 1606 Toro Tinto de Toro
Best Toro I've ever tasted. — 10 years ago
Bonny Doon Vineyard
La Reina Vineyard Chardonnay 1990
This is another I assumed I'd be pouring down the drain but after 25 years it's surprisingly good. Not much fruit left but some nice tertiary flavor and plenty of acid. Perhaps no one but me and @Patrick Emerson would enjoy this Apologies to @Randall Grahm but my rating reflects the current condition. — 10 years ago
Kirkland Signature
Côtes du Rhône Villages Red Rhone Blend 2012
Matt had this 11 years ago
Trader Joe's
Charles Shaw Blend California Cabernet Sauvignon 2010
I used to blind myself with $2C against Three Wishes a lot. Customers would ask me which was better or if they came out of the same tank. I've had this bottle laying around for a few years and it's better than I remember. It's pretty boring but there's nothing objectionable about it.
I did not however finish the bottle.
Biltmore Estate
Cardinal's Crest Red Blend
This is NV but the sales manager gave it to me at Riverside Wine in 2000, so it's older than that. I fully expected to take a sip and pour this down the drain at this age but it's showing extremely well. — 10 years ago
G.D. Vajra
Langhe Rosso Nebbiolo Blend 2011
Matt had this 11 years ago
Matt Cory
Matt had this 9 years ago