Comparing both side by side. Left is Dijon 777 clone and right is F105 German clone. They are same year, same soil, same wine maker, same process. And uncorked and poured simultaneously. Color is almost identical. But flavor and aroma is really different. The 777 opened faster, is more aromatic, brighter cherry, a bit floral. The F105 is deeper, earthier, and has a different fruit characteristic, not sure what it is though. Sour cherry with a hint of balsamic? — 15 days ago
Unfortunately I can’t rate this. It is mildly corked. Really a hint, but it is suppressing the wine and cutting the fruit and finish out with a flat bit of cardboard. (We had a discussion and a disagreement on whether it was corked or not, it was faint and not noticeable to my wife but to me clearly corked). — 8 days ago
New world Syrah is just so different from the Rhône. Deeper, darker, denser, though still mid weight and gentle. Much lighter smoke characteristics, more cassis, plum, dark berries. Some green bell pepper too. Smooth, very mild hint of the oak. Integrated soft tannins. Nice long finish. — 10 days ago
Mmmmm. Smoky, earthy, rich, dense, smooth. Tea, raisins, tobacco notes, reasonably integrated structure with some heft. Nothing like a good 15 year old Aglianico with the mouthfeel and finish of a young Amarone. — a month ago
Raun Kupiec
Burst of fruit and flowers in the nose. Raspberry, strawberry, cassis, licorice. Smooth, prominent but integrated tannins on the side of the tongue and cheeks. Lonnng finish. Prime drinking window. Exquisite. — 13 hours ago