Matthew Cohen

9.0

Young cherry fruit. Very bright and young. Early season cherries. — 2 years ago

Benjamin Hickey

9.0

Minerals with good fruit in the blend. Matured on clay pots — 10 years ago

Matthew Cohen

9.2

@delectable lunarossa rosato costacielo I want to love this. Great fruit. Some acidity. Balanced. It lacks some oomph/vibrancy. A little acidity and a blast of minerality. Needs energy on the palate. It’s tasty but lacks the vibrancy I want in a rose. A very good value but not the rockstar its brethren are. ... a bizarre rose. Getting some candied lemon peel internal aromatics. Some savoriness. If I ignore the fact that it’s a rose I like it better. There must be something profound in that statement. ... ok. So after an hour I’m getting some licorice. Some lovely bitterness It tastes almost like rose made from aglianico ... which is what is it. Lovely nose. A field of blackberry flowers with white pepper. Forget every complaint. This is really good after an hour. A rose that needs a decant. Or even some age. Bizarre. Almost like a rose made in burgundy from aglianico. Yes. I’m aware that makes no sense. ... now some grippy acidity on the finish. So elegant on the palate. Juicy. Crushed flowers. Wow. — 6 years ago

Matthew Cohen

9.1

Costacielo fiano nose is smoky with some minerals. Palate has nice fiano fruit. Mineral. Great acidic balance. Fresh. Really well made. Finish is mineral and almost has a hint of spice. A hint of richness. But not so much so it’s obsequious. ... very juicy and balanced — 6 years ago