Really special. — 6 years ago
Dusty roses, chocolate truffle, notes of vanilla, cola, white pepper and tobacco on the nose. 75/25 cab sauv/cab franc. On the palette, this wine is barely getting into its peak at this point (give it 2-5 more years for optimal experience); cola and cherry notes come on strong with tobacco lingering into a slow fade with notes of cranberry, red plum, and fig. Yum!! — 6 years ago
Wow! This wine is stellar!! It was released in screw cap so it is still raring to go for at least a few more years (if not several). Black cherry/blackberry, violets and fleshy notes on the nose. Add in some stone fruit, wet concrete and just a hint of graphite on the palette, and wow! This is a very pleasing wine. — 7 years ago
Second day, waaaay better. JM does not disappoint in my opinion. — 8 years ago
Juicy, pine cone, black currant, spicy at first, delicious! — 10 years ago
Un Auxey-Duresses Les Hautées 2016 de JM Vincent que j’ai trouvé bien, avec des arômes de miel et de fruits jaunes, une certaine richesse et largeur qui domine l’acidité un peu trop. Me semblait meilleur en jeunesse. 88-89
A nice bottle, some yellow orchard fruit and honey, the palate is dominated by the richness and roundness vs a backward acidity, not bad but was better in it’s youth if my memory serves me right.
— 5 years ago
Red berries, a touch of cinnamon and spices. Fresh, elegant, lots of energy, nice soft tannins, well balanced, the most approchable and less powerful of all the premier crus from JM Vincent, very good, drank in a flash. 89-90
Fruits, rouges, touche de canelle. Frais, fin, énergique avec des tannins présents mais tellement approchables en ce moment, bien équilibré et le moins puissant des premiers crus de ce domaine, très bon, ça se boit tout seul. 89-90
— 6 years ago
Aging well. This medium bodied wine is still full of tannin and flavor. It will probably continue to age well for another 5-6 years. Bright red fruit (red plum, strawberry and cranberry) are backed up by a heady/boozy finish and some nice spicy notes (dried red pepper and maybe nutmeg/baking spice). Yum! — 8 years ago
Totally delicious. — 9 years ago
This was a step up from the others and that typical Caillerets saltiness gave it personality and backbone. Lovely, and with the Amuse Bouche of a single slice of the most succulent octopus I've ever had from One Star Michelin chef JM Carette it was a match made in heaven — 10 years ago
2016 vintage. Domaine de l'Ostal is owned by famous Bordeaux winemaker Jean-Michel Cazes (Pauillac Cru Classé Château Lynch-Bages and more recently Haut-Batailley). We can reasonably expect him to not put his name on a bad wine, and this Estobal (the second wine of the estate, the top wine being labeled Domaine de l'Ostal Grand Vin) surely delivers. Dark red. Intense perfume of blackberry jam, rosemary and dried flowers. Mouthfilling layered jammy fruit, with good acidity, smooth tannin and good spicy length. — 6 years ago
Great wine! Wolfgangs with jm. — 7 years ago
PNP > I liked it more in its youth 2008/09
Timeframe for my Fruit Forward pallet. Dr. Jay Miller -Wine Advocate Staffer rated 98 points
in 2007. Cheers 🍇🍷 Dr. Jay Miller Review:
“Any aspiring collectors should add a case of this to their stash. The 2004 Numanthia comes from a different terroir with a different clone of Tinta de Toro. The vines for this cuvee range from 70-100 years of age with tiny yields of 1 ton of fruit per acre. The wine undergoes malolactic fermentation in barrel followed by 19 months in new French oak before being bottled unfined and unfiltered. The wine is a glass-coating opaque purple with a killer nose of mineral, pencil lead, wild blueberry, and blackberry liqueur that roars from the glass. On the palate the wine is full-bodied, dense, and already beginning to show complexity within its layers of spicy black fruits. There is immense power, well-concealed ripe tannin, and the well-delineated finish lasts for over one minute. This is a sensational effort which in a perfect world should be cellared for a decade and enjoyed over the following 25+ years. However, the elderly among us should not feel guilty about opening a bottle now. (JM) (2/2007)” — 7 years ago
Red mtn. all the way (i.e. huge fruit and a hint of banana), with softer tannins (thanks to aging perhaps) and a sweet lingering finish. Yum! — 10 years ago
Brian handke
Simple, clean finish, easy to drink. JM Italian Steakhouse — 3 years ago