McGah Family Cellars

Scarlett Cabernet Sauvignon

9.331 ratings
9.35 pro ratings
Rutherford, Napa Valley, California, USA
Cabernet Sauvignon
Onion, Shallot, Garlic, Pasta, Venison, Tomato-Based, Potato, Pork, Chocolate & Caramel, White Rice, Mushrooms, Beef, Lamb, Chili & Hot Spicy
Top Notes For
Ron R
9.4

I’m like a broken record on this wine. So consistent. So good! In the $65 range, this is tough to improve on.

I’m like a broken record on this wine. So consistent. So good! In the $65 range, this is tough to improve on.

Jul 22nd, 2018
Ron R
9.4

Such a brilliant effort. No more prose required.

Such a brilliant effort. No more prose required.

Mar 11th, 2018
Ron R
9.3

Tasted many times in the recent past - sublime showing. We love this producer since he produced a great wine at a very reasonable price - @ Keste Pizzeria on Bleecker St, NYC.

Tasted many times in the recent past - sublime showing. We love this producer since he produced a great wine at a very reasonable price - @ Keste Pizzeria on Bleecker St, NYC.

Mar 3rd, 2018
Ron R
9.4

We love everything about this wine.

We love everything about this wine.

2 people found it helpfulMar 26th, 2018
Jay Kline

This was a random, lonely bottle in my cellar and it was a Napa Cab sort of night so figured it was as good a time as any to give this a whirl. Besides, a few of my friends had recently made some comments about how well the 2015’s were showing so it was only more incentive to open this.

We pulled the cork a couple of hours prior and consumed over a several hour period. No formal notes. The first impression is “holy smokes this is absolutely packed with sweet, ripe fruits”. It was shocking. The quality of the fruit is seriously high…a black and red fruit combo with some baking spices…but it’s so jammy and primary that I couldn’t pull much more from it. Tannins were medium. Acid was medium/medium-. The texture is silky smooth. Finish is long-ish due to the mouth-coating fruit. Ultimately however, I struggled to fully enjoy this due to wonderful fruit being let down by the lack of structure which left it coming across a bit flabby. That being said, this style is intentional and arguably very popular. Drink now.

This was a random, lonely bottle in my cellar and it was a Napa Cab sort of night so figured it was as good a time as any to give this a whirl. Besides, a few of my friends had recently made some comments about how well the 2015’s were showing so it was only more incentive to open this.

We pulled the cork a couple of hours prior and consumed over a several hour period. No formal notes. The first impression is “holy smokes this is absolutely packed with sweet, ripe fruits”. It was shocking. The quality of the fruit is seriously high…a black and red fruit combo with some baking spices…but it’s so jammy and primary that I couldn’t pull much more from it. Tannins were medium. Acid was medium/medium-. The texture is silky smooth. Finish is long-ish due to the mouth-coating fruit. Ultimately however, I struggled to fully enjoy this due to wonderful fruit being let down by the lack of structure which left it coming across a bit flabby. That being said, this style is intentional and arguably very popular. Drink now.

1 person found it helpfulJan 8th, 2023
TheSkip

This showed exceptionally well! I thought the 15s might have already lost their steam but clearly not.

This showed exceptionally well! I thought the 15s might have already lost their steam but clearly not.

Jun 27th, 2020
Laith A

Had side by side with the Outpost cab! This thing held its own and then some... smooth as silk with sweet, ripe tannins and tons of black and blue fruits! @Mike Smith great work!

Had side by side with the Outpost cab! This thing held its own and then some... smooth as silk with sweet, ripe tannins and tons of black and blue fruits! @Mike Smith great work!

May 24th, 2020
TheSkip

This is starting to gain a bit of complexity and is exiting its early youth. Very nice!

This is starting to gain a bit of complexity and is exiting its early youth. Very nice!

Feb 20th, 2020
Grant Everett

Came across a little overly sweet tonight

Came across a little overly sweet tonight

Jul 27th, 2019
TheSkip

Happy 4th! One of my favs but at this tender age, this fair lass is showing her age. I enjoyed her youthful exuberance.

Happy 4th! One of my favs but at this tender age, this fair lass is showing her age. I enjoyed her youthful exuberance.

Jul 4th, 2019