Norman Gennaro

9.0

Very different inho. I get brown sugar and a bit of wood and pecan in the nose. The flavors are surprisingly strong with more brown sugar for me and a bit of alcohol. It’s got a long finish but it’s not totally up my alley. Maybe because I went with the younger one first not knowing it was peat forward. — a month ago

Seth W

9.6

Very smooth light Smokey finish — 4 years ago

Jim McCusker

9.6

No longer made...which is a crime! — 6 years ago

with Vanessa

Norman Gennaro

9.0

Benromach 7yr 2011 Triple Distilled ABV 40%. The nose is light but nice. Struggling to define it, lightly sweet for me with a hit of wood. It’s hot on the palate but that’s the first sip. Little to no bite and the finish is quick. — 3 months ago

Norman Gennaro

9.4

WhiskeyFest SF 2022 - (reused glass so not doing tasting notes) a bit stronger than the 1979. Preferred that to this. — 2 years ago

Punit Kanwar

8.9

Reall smooth slightly fruity and creamy — 8 years ago

Antoine Pin

Wine Buyer Kroger/QFC

9.1

This has become my favorite single malt producer. Amazing I can still taste it. — 8 years ago

Raun Kupiec

8.9

2023 Whisky Advent Calendar, Day 9: this is actually the Benromach Contrasts: Peat Smoke small batch in Bourbon casks. To me the nose is all smoke, not much else. But the first taste on sipping is intense tropical fruits and ginger. But then the peat comes back in the finish, though not as intense as on the nose. It’s good, at first not my thing but it grows on you. — a year ago

Aaron Tan

9.4

I don't particularly care for peated whisky, but this bottle was nothing short of brilliant. The finesse was absolutely mind-boggling - not something I had expected out of a dram made with high levels of peat smoke, at 67 ppm.

Again, I'm not very good with whiskies and it's not often I write notes on it, but this just demanded the attention. Perhaps the best peated whisky I've had.

Tasted neat. Very elegant smoke, if that even makes sense. Neither harsh, nor overpowering. There's a citrusy, spice box, and sea-spray element to the nose too. Palate feels quite rich, kinda like smoking a cigar and eating creme caramel with candied pineapples. The finish is smooth, long, spicy, and smoky. With ice/water, I got more of the oak, but the more delicate citrusy elements started appearing on the palate. The smoke also feels more savoury than cigar-like, kinda like that smokiness in smoked foods. A real joy to sip on.

NB: Distilled 2006, bottled 2016. Another user's tasting note sums this up very well - strong peat, light scotch 🤣 — 6 years ago

Trent Wong

9.3

Little more bite then McCallan — 8 years ago