Bob McDonald

9.3

Had a bottle 66 weeks ago - this is my last bottle. White florals. The palate is delicate, restrained and polished. After a while sweet fruit but undeniably more citrus than stone fruit. The finish shows cleansing citric acid with a touch of salinity. The same notes the following night. 2017 - a good year for white burgundy. — 4 days ago

Tom Casagrande

8.9

This rose is not subtle. The nose explodes with peach, strawberry, navel orange, wet gravel. It’s full-flavored in the mouth, dry, but with tons of fruit upfront. Not-yet-integrated acids create a slight sour note on the finish. Boisterous. — 3 months ago

Andrew McIntyre

9.0

Apricot, orange peel a little bit of oak bound together with an oily structure. Good but not great — 5 months ago

John Howard

Harvest production at Hirsch and Cobb Wineries

9.1

Classic and great. — 20 days ago

Martin Bergo

9.2

Bone dry, woody, austere, with anise, gooseberry, and unripe pineapple. — a month ago

Bruce Leboff

9.4

Boom. Amazing. Classic Pierre a fusille. Drinking beautifully. Long elegant finish. — 3 months ago

with David

Nagib Nasr

8.9

Not my favorite — 23 days ago

Gregory Spock

9.0

Ripe strawberry and raspberry on the nose, but lush full mouth feel with underlining sea water minerality. Great balance and short, but lingering dry finish. — 2 months ago

Alan Snitow

9.2

En magnum - charmes duess — 4 months ago

Alan Weinberg

9.2

Damn but this guy makes great wine — 5 months ago