Austin Hohnke

8.9

@Delectable This is the Montpelain bottling. Serious and structured. Needs air. Raspberry coulis and crushed rocks. Gains weight with air. Aged in concrete egg. More time needed. — 3 months ago

Juan Lopez

10

Excellent Pinot noir. Peppery and nutty. Smooth finish — 2 years ago

Daniel Bloom

9.3

See previous entry.
Still pretty spot on review.
This bottle may have been opened a bit colder, straight out of the keeper.
Still great red/black fruits and chewy.
Granite in your mouth. A very tactile wine. Announces it’s presence without taking over. Refreshing & bright.
Great stuff.
— 3 years ago

Alan Hyde

9.0

Great red fruit. — 5 months ago

John Howard

Harvest production at Hirsch and Cobb Wineries

9.3

Again, amazing. — 2 years ago

Stephane St-Arnauld

9.0

'la grande reserve' — 3 years ago

Silvestre Moreno del Alamo

9.0

Fantastico — 4 years ago

John Willison

9.0

Cranberry, pomegranate, earthy, dry berry compote. — a year ago

Romain Fitoussi

9.1

Red deep fruit colour. Very nice nose of cherry and spices, pepper. In the mouth it is both crunchy and of a beautiful intensity, which will express all the better as the bottle will have been aerated for at least a good hour. An elegant bourguignon beaujolais, with a gastronomic profile that is still a little young. Clearly tailored for long guard. — 2 years ago

Bob Boyle

8.9

Past its prime but still drinkable — 4 years ago