Black cherries, definitely some tobacco hints, floral notes and some raspberry notes IMO — 4 years ago
Firing on all cylinders. Opening with an edge of reduction, fine oak, balanced lees component, similar to a great WBurg. With air it’s varietal character emerged, with ripe citrus, slight kiss of herb, and a complex array of mineral undertones. Incredible energy at 7 years old, one of the great SBs of the world IMO. — 5 years ago
Vintage 1989 | 3/4 transparant, Italian rooftiles brown rim. A very intense bouquet: cedar, forrest wood, laurel, flint, cherries, só multi layered you tend to smell endless. Powerful taste, prominent bitters, still too young imo, the taste comes together with the entrecôte, awesome harmony. A benchmark for wine lovers. Fine that HB delivers to mark a special moment! I bought this when my daughter was born | at restaurant Pollevie — 5 years ago
Popped and poured; enjoyed over the course of an hour while we crushed some sushi at One Flew South, waiting for our connecting flight. It’s been a minute since I’ve had Scharffenberger, let alone the Rosé. Still solid. The wine poured a beautiful pink, salmon color with a moderately persistent mousse of relatively small bubbles. On the nose, the wine is developing with notes of raspberries, faint strawberry, faint peach and lemon citrus with a whiff of brioche. On the palate, dry with refreshing acidity; plenty to work with our sushi. The finish was medium. More than decent value considering the venue. Drink now. As an extra observation, the new label was a pleasant surprise as I felt the previous label was long overdue for a refresh. I don’t always feel that way as I love the labels of some OG producers but this was needed IMO. Bravo. — 3 years ago
Perfectly cellared bottles replete with a firm cork after 27 years! Forest floor on the nose with vibrant color in the glass notes of graphite and cedar stood out from a very balanced and delightfully approachable Margaux with years of life remaining in the cellar IMO. — 4 years ago
has still some elegance left, but overall a little too far imo... — 6 years ago
Amazing, stay away don’t buy, because I want the price point to stay here… very great White… taste more like good French white burgundy IMO! — 3 years ago
Star of the night IMO - beautiful light dessert red, just as I remember it from Verona, far outclassed the Sicilian white, a great (summertime?) alternative to port as a digestif — 3 years ago
Dark fruit but has mellowed over the years or “softened “ definite tobacco and licorice hints and great earth tones but time to drink IMO! — 4 years ago

Pop and pour (!). Nowhere near the brett levels of previous btls. A lovely PN. On the nose: that CE mushroom funk, a hint of va, soft wild strawberry perfume, soft herbs. On the palate: fantastic acidity, soft plum, and soft vanilla, great density, still a lot of velvety tannin on the finish. On par with the 18 amd 16, not as good as 15 and 17 imo. — 6 years ago
Bob McDonald

A gorgeous red fruited perfumed nose which transfers to the rich totally integrated palate. Definitely one of Australia’s best Pinots and IMO as good as its Reserve in many years (the latter being significantly more expensive than the Premium). The new owner Jacques Fourrier now charges round $1500 for the Reserve so I have stopped buying it. I recently served the 2017 Premium blind to my wine tasting group and they all picked it as a Burgundy. — 2 months ago