Eric Grasser

9.4

Magnum purchased at the winery. Rested 9 weeks at home. Stunning balance for an ultra hot vintage. While showcased by the crystalline quartzite (sea stone personality in an area of thin slate) the wine is still driven by the pure harmony of tartaric acid, European delicacy of yellow apple, pear, quince, hay flavors and the light kiss of Czechian oak. In pure harmony - nothing aggressive. Sophisticated yet anyone would recognize its brilliance — 6 months ago

Matthew Cohen

9.5

Nose is a hint of lemon oil.

Palate is gorgeously rich. Wow. Delicious. Mineral. — 2 years ago

Martin Bergo

9.3

With >200 yrs of family history in Rheingau, this producer naturally grows mostly Riesling, but this PN is stunning. Medium-deep ruby brick color; nose of red and blue small ripe fruits, pronounced spiciness, and new oak but in amounts best described by the Swedish word ”lagom” (just enough); low alcohol but with a respectable structure from acids and small tannins, mouthfilling and a long finish where violets, mint, strawberries, and herbs linger. — 3 years ago

Kamall

9.0

Silky and spicy. — 8 months ago

Freek Welter

9.4

94+, young — a year ago

S.S. Mandani

9.3

Love this crisp bouquet, a cold night, still. The stars pristine sharp dots draping the sky. Mineral driven. Apples.

Bracing. Sharp. Energetic acidity with legs, carrying a savory quality through the mid.

Zip and chew. Something to sip and think. — 3 years ago

Sarah Hughes

10

Loved it. A neighbor gave us his before he moved. It had been sitting for years. It's amazing! — 10 months ago

Matthew Cohen

9.5

Nose : powdery minerals gorgeous white flowers. Really gorgeous. So elegnat. 9.8 nose.

Palate: minerals yellow fruits. Sweet lemon. Wow — a year ago

Magdalice Gutiérrez

9.5

Sweet and soft taste. Delicious. — 3 years ago

Meg Herring

9.2

Very peachy! Also lots of lime. Like a big squeeze of lime, and the pith too. This leans savory for me. — 3 years ago