Patti Gamboni

9.5

Yum yum yum — 7 months ago

Emily Kresie-Harrington

9.0

2016 vintage. Very clean and linear with lots of white flower, green apple, tangerine, green pear, nectarine, and red papaya notes. A touch sweeter than traditional Kabinett, but not over the top. — 7 years ago

Christopher Bates

Master Sommelier, Owner/Winemaker Element Winery

9.4

One of the best bottles of Riesling I have had in a long time. Perfectly minty, touch of oxidation but perfectly pure. — 10 years ago

Christian Adams

9.1

Clarity, acid for days and a power punch of fruit. Bäm! — 11 years ago

Judd Blair

9.0

Riesling attack! Still trying to wrap my head around these guys - this one is a bit sweeter than I'm used to, wine soda, but I imagine thats a shortcoming of my palette and not this wine, which has some pretty great fruit and minerals behind it. — 12 years ago

Doug Powers

9.3

Another brilliant 2001 German Riesling, ABV is lower on this Mosel than the Donnhoff Nahe from last week, crisp, super fresh, lively, just enough sweetness to match with a lemon cake for dessert, long, lingering finish!! — 7 months ago

with Jim

Angelo Casagrande

9.0

Thoroughly enjoyable. Crisp pear/ apple- great acidity and a touch of the sweet. Have to save my second bottle for my brother. — 8 years ago

Wei-cheng Hsueh

9.0

Outstanding !!! — 11 years ago

Charlie Beatty

Buyer wineworksonline.com

9.7

Petrol normal on nose, even with age it really a classic Great Auslese dessert from buddy Ron Sanders!! — 12 years ago

Stephen George

9.4

Tallest mag I've ever seen. The juice matches the grandeur of the bottle. Gorgeous nose -- minerals, pear skin, snatches of petrol. Palate explodes with snappy acidity, suave texture, sweet fleshy mid-palate, refreshing salinity throughout, and long unctuous finish. 7 years old, but incredibly youthful. — 13 years ago

Eunyoung Cho

9.0

Sour not strong not sweet — 6 years ago

Phil

8.9

Very good. Slight sweetness but dry — 8 years ago

Matthew Heywood

9.5

Delicious. Like liquid gold. — 9 years ago

Dade Thieriot

10

Talk about " closet vintages"...2004s are rarely mentioned in discussions of great German vintages over the past 15-20 years, but people are really missing the boat.
The'04s are classic #Mosel #Rieslings with awesome balance and structure, together with ideal acidity levels for long term aging.
Cooler weather vintages such as #2004, which produce wines of greater restraint and less opulence, are less and less common with the onset of global warming, but they are the ones that true Riesling freaks covet most highly--this #Prälat was totally mind blowing!!! #Loosen #ErdenerPrälat #Auslese — 11 years ago

with Petra and Wietske

Lyle Fass

Founder Fass Selections

9.5

Rich, vibrant, honeyed. Love Monchoff in 2005. — 12 years ago