Juan Pablo Perez

9.1

Nariz: mora, arandano, regaliz, especies, violetas, aromas primarios todavia. Nariz bonita.

Boca: Tanino M/M+, Acidez M, Alcohol M/M+ — 14 days ago

Pinotman /// Andreas

9.6

I think i am one of the few who has back vintages all the way to 2009. So I take these reviews seriously. Even the winery has little if any left. This is extraordinary - fresh raspberries and the E&M classic black forest herbs. Mostly thyme. Cardamom, lime, crushed marble. If you have the wine - taste how this wine unfolds. I would not decant this! Drink up this vintage. And would drink this from 5-60 min after opening. On the super elegant light side. Color almost like a Rose. The E&M style is always there, the quality super high. But sometimes there is variability from vintage to vintage. This is ethereal and super light on its feet but has a depth which is difficult to explain. — a month ago

Juan Pablo Perez

9.0

Nariz: mora, ciruela, frambuesa, algo de regaliz y especies, aceitunas

Boca: Tanino M, Acidez M/M+, Alcohol M — 8 months ago

Ely Cohn

9.0

Fruity, austere, and wild. One of the few Rose's you could spot in a lineup - distinct E&M natty twang in a lucid cherry crimson glow, a little bit candied, sour, and herbaceous.

Wild sour cherry, strawberries and cream, and dark green rosemary.

— 18 days ago

Pinotman /// Andreas

9.4

Tasted the E&M line up at the winery. It was mind blowing!!!!!🤯. These are the best wines they ever made. Both the reds and the whites were great from top to bottom. Kirsch Sauerkirsche, red currant, tart.
Light and elegant hint herbs a stupido good wine. And for the price unbeatable. — 2 months ago

Chris Palmer

9.4

From Naked Wines. E, M and I all enjoyed it — 7 months ago

with Edward

Pinotman /// Andreas

8.9

Wild and animalistic. For sure not something i would expect from a GC. The guests liked it but mostly i think for the GC label. The wine needs tons of air. But it tends to be overoxided before the limited flavors comes through. And i just can’t ignore that. For sure no match at all for an E&M big boy not even close. Pretty harsh tannins, orange rind and essentially almost no fruit. — 8 months ago

Pinotman /// Andreas

9.3

A little VA which blows off. Then a cherry freak show which calms down. Dark and morello cherries. Chalky. 13.5%. Quite rich and a little atypical for E&M. Needs more time to resolve fruit (3-5 years). — a month ago

Pinotman /// Andreas

9.2

No funk whatsoever the orange wines of E&M all rock. — 2 months ago

Pinotman /// Andreas

9.7

Fleshy and big at this point with amazing tannins. Too young. Cherry 🍒 driven at this point - the classic E&M black forest herbs are there. Seems to me comparable to a GC Vosne. This is a tremendous effort and will improve over time to a glorious benchmark Pinot. I suspect my rating will go up to a 9.8+ in 5 years. What a wine! Should have bought cases! — 2 months ago