TJ Maxwell

9.7

2005 vintage under screwcap. I little pssst when opened lol. Really great example right out of the gate. Lots of intense black fruit, game-y, herb-y aromas. The color was remarkably deep garnet and not too advanced. Slight tawnyness happening on the rim a bit. Palate was intense but balanced. Lots of typical CdP elements throughout. Great acidity. What a fantastic bottle! This is California’s best Rhône wine and it’s not even close — 10 days ago

Lauren Lathrop

9.0

Big fruit very good. Enjoyed at dinner at Cochon in Nola with friends — a year ago

Diana Fischer

9.9

From frannies market — 4 years ago

John Howard

Harvest production at Hirsch and Cobb Wineries

9.3

Killler. Insane value at Costco for $11. — 2 months ago

John Howard

Harvest production at Hirsch and Cobb Wineries

9.1

Old school style. Organic with no flaws. Def. Garrigue. Still good after being open a few days. Great! — 7 months ago

Emerson Warden

9.5

Easy to drink. Fruit forward. Refreshing with light acidity. — 3 years ago

John Howard

Harvest production at Hirsch and Cobb Wineries

9.0

Good as per usual. — 4 months ago

Frank Lin

8.9

Great wine! Fruity and well balanced. Tasty. — 6 months ago

Avery Plank

9.0

After 30 minutes of decanting all of the sharp acidity rounded out & it is like a baby CdP. Great value wine. — 2 years ago

Francis le cave

9.1

Bouteille orpheline exposée dans la vitrine du restaurant le Pied de cochon à Montréal, transformé temporairement, pandémie oblige, en pizzeria/caviste. Une fois les formalités d'adoption complétées, ce rosé n'a pas eu à patienter longtemps avant de rencontrer la vrille. On est loin ici du rosé de canicule. Sérieux, séveux, avec un profil aromatique assez unique et difficilement descriptible. On y trouve un petit fruit rouge, mais en mode mineur. La courte finale nous empêche d'exagérer la notation, mais ne gâche en rien l'expérience. Beau hasard! — 5 years ago