Nagging Doubt

Isole e Olena

Cepparello Estate Bottled Toscana Sangiovese 2016

See previous note in November 2024. Same notes still apply. Rich cherry and spice. Previous note said drink the last one in mid 2026, so I was close and the previous notes still apply. Morrell said that 2016 is “without a doubt, the finest vintage for Chianti Classico.” Excellent. — 2 months ago

Ira, Tom and 16 others liked this

Henschke

Hill of Grace Vineyard Shiraz 1996

Only pale to mid crimson in colour with a tawny edge at 26 years of age. Black and blue fruits with game and a coffee bean note. The medium bodied yet rich palate is savoury and earthy with blackberry and just so so silky with resolved tannins and low acid. Not sure that I agree totally with Bob Campbell MW’s description - “like getting into an old Jag on a hot day”, but I love the imagery and can see where he’s coming from. Jancis said “pure hedonism “ and gave it 19/20. The latest iteration of H of G (2017) is selling for around $950 a bottle in Brisbane. No doubt brilliant but too expensive for me. I remember paying $12.50 for the 1982 vintage on release. There is a certain H of G character that is recognisable over many vintages over the years. Must be one of the most unique Shiraz vineyards in the world with vines up to a 150 years old. A privilege to drink this wine and close to perfection with 98 points. — 5 years ago

Matt, Ira and 25 others liked this
Jan A

Jan A

Definitely one of my bucket list wines! Thank you for the review!
Bob McDonald

Bob McDonald Influencer Badge Premium Badge

My pleasure Jan. A worthy wine to have in anyone’s bucket list I would say. Cheers. 🍷

Paul Lato

The Manga Girl Rosé of Pinot Noir 2019

Easily one of the best CA roses I’ve ever had (and at $25, without a doubt the best QPR). Absolutely terrific wine. — 7 years ago

Vanessa McCaffrey
with Vanessa
Mike, Paul and 7 others liked this

Bodegas Alto Moncayo

Veraton Garnacha 2015

Nice wine without a doubt but too much power, sun, too jammy. QPR not in balance — 7 years ago

Neil, Severn and 7 others liked this

Bodegas Alto Moncayo

Campo de Borja Garnacha 2007

No doubt. 100 pts. Goose bump and getting a place in my wine-momentum list. Especially one of the longest aftertaste red wines evert tried — 9 years ago

Jeroen, Freek and 1 other liked this

William Hill Estate Winery

Napa Valley Cabernet Sauvignon 2014

Continuing in my Napa cab education this showed up at the door for me. It is excellent winter wine. It would warm you even if chilled—at 15 % abv no doubt but the taste is coziness defined too: ripe cherries, blackberry preserves on some sort of cheese on an earthy whole whole wheat cracker. The tannins could use, say, one or two more years to fully integrate but they aren’t objectable. Holiday spices and a whiff of forest floor and a long plummy finish round it out. Take this wine to an ice skating party if such things exist in your life. — 9 years ago

Ira, Chris and 17 others liked this

Bodegas Faustino

Gran Reserva Faustino I Rioja Tempranillo Blend 2001

Geoff Troup
8.9

Pretty good. Definitely budget friendly. I've had a few too many stellar old world riojas lately that this doesn't compare to. Anyhow....

Baked raisin on the nose. Smells cooked but it's not cooked. Some soft dried fruits. On the palate...at first huge acid and petrol. Automotive stuff going on all around. After an hour in the decanter, the acid is dialed down to a gentle roar, demanding to be noticed but not taking over. Notes of eucalyptus, lilacs, dried bitter black cherry in the mid palate. Still very lively and certainly kicking...tannin has dissipated and the structure and flavors are quite harmonious. Definitely in a good spot now. Could go considerably longer, but I doubt it will improve beyond this. Nice value for Gran reserve rioja.
— 10 years ago

Matt Pyrch
with Matt

Vincent Dancer

La Romanée Chassagne-Montrachet 1er Cru Chardonnay 2022

From one of the absolute best sites in Chassagne, the ‘22 vintage and third vintage from Theo Dancer is expectedly superb, and the sunny and impeccably located La Romanée vineyard is profoundly textural, satiny and incisive with a particularly citrusy profile with freshly baked bread and chalky minerality. This is of course, still very young and is without a doubt built to age. — a year ago

Tom, Dave and 8 others liked this

Château Segur de Cabanac

St. Estèphe Red Bordeaux Blend 2015

No doubt my favorite appellation in Bordeaux. Excellent value at 38€ — 5 years ago

Pooneet and Jason liked this
Pooneet K

Pooneet K

Interesting! Mine is St Julien.
Michael Coscetta

Michael Coscetta

I love St Julien as well

Château Gruaud Larose

Saint-Julien Red Bordeaux Blend 1986

Wine Nerd Herd virtual tasting. 86’Château Gruaud Larose.
12.5 ALC. Ruby in color with light amber edges. Decanted it for 90 minutes. Nose- 😳Ripe cherry, sweet spices, herb, tobacco. Dense, full- bodied. Plum, blackberries. With a long velvety tannins.Tasting great today. Without a doubt a 60 year wine.
— 6 years ago

David, Eric and 76 others liked this
Severn G

Severn G Influencer Badge Premium Badge

Not seeing any lack of color concentration there, '86 so solid.
David L

David L Influencer Badge Premium Badge

@Andrew Schirmer Just incredible. Had it over 4 hours.
David L

David L Influencer Badge Premium Badge

@Severn Goodwin Seriously it got 20 + years in it.

La Rioja Alta

Viña Ardanza Reserva Selección Especial Tempranillo Blend 2010

What a beauty. Worlds apart from the 2009 (both wines brilliant in their own right) but this 2010 Seleccion Especial is a much more elegant wine, showing more characteristics of age and less of the aggression shown by its predecessor. I think if anything the 2009 should be longer lived - this is brilliant now and no doubt will be for years to come but it doesn’t have the youthful exuberance of the ‘09. Still, a beautiful Rioja that will provide many years of enjoyment. — 7 years ago

Ira liked this

Paloma

Napa Valley Merlot 2012

This wine has a lot of things going on. Immediately after cork pop, this bottle seems to be a little flat with a muted nose, modest (at best) acidity, and next to no tannin. Well, 30 minutes later and this Merlot is completely different. This wine is a little more weighted than the 2011. Not calling the 2011 'thin' by any means, but this one has some torque no doubt. Pours a dusty violet to the glass. The nose is baked cherries and some darker milk chocolate. The entry of this wine has sharp acidity, dark chocolate cherry cordials with some pretty damn good liqueur here. For a split second, a little bit sweet in the middle. Finish is acidic. Tannin seems to be there, but not significantly. Allows for a beautiful finish. — 9 years ago

Paul, M. Christopher and 22 others liked this

Fattoria di Fèlsina Berardenga

Riserva Rancia Chianti Classico Sangiovese Blend 2012

There is a lot going on here. Every component is still looking for a way to blend in. Quite tannic. Long finish. Clearly a bright future. I loved it already now and gave it the benefit of the doubt and pushed it into my 9.0 scoring. — 9 years ago

Isaac, Brandyn and 1 other liked this

Château Lafite Rothschild

Pauillac Red Bordeaux Blend 1996

I have been surprised more than once over how certain vintages of Lafite can seem muted for a long time and then miraculous bounce back and show fantastic at 30+ years.
That being said I doubt this will ever reach the 98-100 range for me....
(1995 enjoyed a few months ago was in a different league).
— 10 years ago

Kenneth Korsbæk
with Kenneth
Jason, Keith and 22 others liked this

E. Guigal

La Turque Côte-Rôtie Syrah 2007

While no doubt a young La La, 2007 La Turque is fabulous tonight, wafting layers of violets, campfire smoke, black olive, smoked meats and deep dark fruit. It’s multidimensional palate is seriously concentrated, yet simultaneously shows elegance and lift, all leading to its long, silky finish. In a great spot but also with many years ahead. — 4 years ago

Jan, Vino and 5 others liked this

Alphonse Mellot

La Moussière Sancerre Sauvignon Blanc 2020

Delectable Wine
8.9

The 2020 Sancerre La Moussière is an easygoing wine offering clean, pure flavors of pineapple, grass and pear. It's full and rounded with a whopping 15% alcohol, which no doubt has boosted the texture and palate weight. (Rebecca Gibb MW, Vinous, August 2021)
— 5 years ago

Grosset

Polish Hill Clare Valley Riesling 2004

ESF
9.2

Very interesting to see this age - upon release this was extremely tight & austere and now it has blossomed into a beautifully expressive aged Riesling w/dark gold color, big whiff of petrol alongside peach & apricot. On the palate it is still razor sharp & angular w/only slightly rounded off edges no doubt due to age & bit of fat it gained. On the finish it is bone dry with clearly defined lemon & lime, mineral-y w/hint of creaminess. — 6 years ago

David, Josh and 8 others liked this
Bob McDonald

Bob McDonald Influencer Badge Premium Badge

Great restraint on your part to be drinking this at 17 years - one of Australia’s best.
ESF

ESF

Bob: did not have access to my cellar for the last 5 years, but I knew these were built for the long run. I love Clare Valley wines (red & white) and I used to sell Grosset... I have more of these & will revisit in a few years

Seavey Vineyard

Caravina Napa Valley Cabernet Sauvignon 2017

We opened this bottle late on Friday night and poured off a small glass to see what we were working with. As I suspected, far too young with loads of energy, rolls of baby fat and frankly, not very well behaved. So we pressed the cork back in the bottle and figured we would try our luck the next day when my parents stopped by for a socially distant glass of wine to “celebrate” Easter together. I’m so glad we waited. Twelve or so hours of slow-ox made a huge difference. While it was still very primary, it was much more enjoyable showing a strong core of dark berries, tobacco, leather, coffee and baking spices. But again, where Seavey really excels is texture and sense of place. To be expected for mountain fruit at this age, the tannins are firm but reasonable and there is such lovely acid that screams Howell Mountain. I have no doubt this will have a very bright future! In my mind, Caravina is probably the greatest “second” wine in Napa. This is Seavey’s 19th and latest vintage of Caravina. After an extended drought, 2017 began with torrential rain that flooded the valley. The fruit comes entirely from steep hillside blocks on the estate and is otherwise made in the same fashion as the Grand Vin. If you’re going to drink one now, I highly recommend a lengthy decant as these are easily 10 years away from their best. — 7 years ago

Arden, Daniel and 7 others liked this
Somm David T

Somm David T Influencer Badge

Really like the style of their wines.

Sandhi Wines

Santa Barbara County Chardonnay 2014

Blind tasted. Nose is very tight; star fruit, green apple, hints of poolside vapors. First sip is intense, acidic and tight as well, a few chews revealing structure and contained complexity. A nice buttery and ripe fruit retro really shows the quality of the wine, in conclusion. Very hard to describe - a thinker - that's for sure. Still very young - a sleeper - that's no doubt, pleasure was partly intellectual. I'd recommend to carafe for half a day or to taste the bottle over a few days. Taste around 14 degrees. Impressive !@Rajat Parr — 9 years ago

Marco Bergevin
with Marco
Riddley, P and 9 others liked this

Hubert Lamy

Les Frionnes Saint-Aubin 1er Cru Chardonnay 2014

Scorewine
8.9

Delicious starting to open up and show it's true potential, light citrus, lots of crushed stones, mineral, a hidden hint of litchi and grapefruit, medium body, creamy yet highly vibrant with crisp mineral acidity, long delicious fresh finish. I have to be strong and wait a bit longer it will pay off no doubt. My score 88 (with a clear 90 potential) , drink to 2022 — 9 years ago

Scorewine, Sharon and 20 others liked this