2006 is a sweet bomb, honeysuckle goodness. — 8 years ago
A favorite of Sabrina's, found while tasting on a day out in the city. This was the first wine she's tasted different vintages on. The difference for the Montigny was stark. — 9 years ago
Absolutely outstanding bottle! Stone fruit galore, ending with some salinity. — 4 months ago
Beautiful nose, full or ripe citrus, a touch of yellow stone fruit, candied orange peel, a bit exotic, but also a bit wild. There’s incredible cool freshness here, despite the ripeness. So enticing!
On the palate with racy, juicy, electric acidity but also ripe stone fruit, a slight touch of tannic grip, a brilliant stony minerality. This has great depth and brilliant purity but also some interesting edges and a smoky hint to it. Very complex. It’s not bone dry and the touch of wood aging adds a bit of creaminess.
I wouldn’t call it elegant but this is a great wine, full of character and energy.
Absolutely brilliant. And drinking so beautifully right now. — 10 months ago
Petrol upon opening with hint of cats pee and cigarettes (in a good way). Not especially acidic but quite dry. Still very fun to sip. Would be great at 2/3rds the price. — 4 years ago
Maybe not the fireworks of a Dönnhoff or Schönleber, but a damn good glass of Nahe from a big, fatty vintage. Yellow cherries and ripe pineapple, buttressed by excellent structure and barely-there wet slate minerality. — 7 years ago
The trifecta - 2004, Lay (coolest plot of Halenberg), and magnum! This is pinnacle level stuff. Took its time to open up, but when it did... Mind-altering! The nose was wonderfully complex right from the start. Evolved from smokey stone fruit aromas, to a tropical fruit basket with biscuit-like tones, to more salinity and fresh cut herbs, and finally to a mix of dried citrus with deep calcerous minerality and woody herbs. Crazy. Closed till the end of the bottle, but the balance was undeniable from the get-go. Perfectly integrated acidity, highly concentrated, juicy yellow stone fruits, deep minerality, and endless finish. As SC puts it, at its first peak now, but needs another 10 years to show its best. — 7 years ago

Wow, amazing fine and likewise complex spatlese; thanx Werner; it fits beautiful to the South African style pumpkinsoup I’ve cooked from my late ripend bottlegourds — 9 years ago
100% needs a 45 minute decant now.
Nose: white flowers. Dense. Lemon flower. Intense lemon rind. Really penetrating.
Palate Very lemony. Mineral. Very dense. Crunchy rocks. Grapefruit pith. Lingering. Penetrating.
Emrich schonleber Esque.
Fass selections. — 2 years ago
Brandon Thiessen
Super concentrated and complex; lovely, drier than my preference — 2 months ago