Over & Under

Château Pontet-Canet

Pauillac Red Bordeaux Blend 2003

Ron R
9.5

Good god. Peaking right now.
Huge aromatics on the nose. Superb weight, balance and texture. No rush to consume. Cedar and macerated black cherries transition to coffee and hints of maple. Blew me away. In raptures over this. Direct from the winery when I lived in Europe.
— 15 hours ago

Mo Salem
with Mo
John, Vin and 24 others liked this
Vino Joe

Vino Joe Premium Badge

Wonderful notes! You may have compelled me to break out my lone 2003 this holiday season…
Ron R

Ron R Influencer Badge Premium Badge

@David T, so subjective. Personally, I prefer WS ratings (due to blind tasting scores), but I do my research before investing. I always assume “buyer beware” when I purchase wines.
David T

David T Influencer Badge

@Ron R My point was really this…there are deals/value to be had on the vintages William Kelly reviewed. The Wine Advocate still basically sets prices for wines w/ their reviews. Right or wrong, like it or not. That William Kelly’s reviews were an aberration over other known & used critics reviews who all gave those vintages reviewed by Kelly high 90’s. If you can’t taste a wine before buying it, the logical thing to do is look for similarities in reviews and if you don’t do that, follow the one you agree w/ most. I taste a lot of wine so I don’t have to rely on other critics. But if you don’t taste a lot of wine, the advice I give people is to look for agreement amongst critics. The Pontet Canet vintages reviewed by Kelly I am seeing those priced sub $100. I saw one of those Kelly vintages at Costco yesterday sub $100 and the reason I brought it up. The non Kelly vintages are selling quite a bit higher. This Chateau has produced consist high 90’s scores since 2005 across a wide band of critics. So, the question I ask is, did the Chateau’s quality dip or did a reviewer change? Something to watch and be aware of as a wine buyer. Cheers & happy holidays. 🍷

Château Lafite Rothschild

Pauillac Red Bordeaux Blend 1989

Medium ruby garnet , garnet terracotta rim. Slightly sweet , roasted nose, with chestnut some sous bois , grafite , slight seaside hints. After a while a touch more herbal. On the palate quite stern dark fruits , mineral , grafite notes , quite dry tannin and ok balanced acidity . Reasonable length and sous bois , grafite tinged finish . This is still quite young though its appearance is slightly more advanced than the 1988 . Needs a decant and held up well over the 5 hours we had it open . Drink now and over the next 5-10 years. A little pedestrian overall and is outclassed by the superior 1988. — 2 months ago

Jan, Anthony and 7 others liked this
Shay A

Shay A Influencer Badge Premium Badge

Interesting. Had the ‘89 a few months ago and thought it was on a whole other level compared to the previous ‘88.
Andrew Cullimore

Andrew Cullimore Premium Badge

Interesting comparison with the 1988 @Shay A , I think the 1989 just didn’t show the complexity or persistence on the palate that the 88 showed, however aroma wise it showed more sweetness and fruit . I was also surprised that the 1989 looked a little older, colour wise, than the 1988. I would be perfectly happy to drink either on any day of the week !

Château Léoville-Las Cases

Grand Vin de Leoville du Marquis de las Cases Saint-Julien Red Bordeaux Blend 1982

Opened earlier in the day and double-decanted several hours prior to service; enjoyed over the course of three hours. The 1982 pours a deep garnet with a near opaque core. On the nose, the wine is developing (still!) and slightly green compared to the ’82 Mouton that was poured alongside. Cassis, purple Chewy SweeTarts, green bell pepper, old wood, some earth and baking spices. On the palate, the wine is dry and has massive structure still. Confirming the notes from the nose. The finish is long and slightly bitter. Drink now with a long decant but there are decades of life left. — 4 days ago

Ericsson, Ron and 26 others liked this
Vino Joe

Vino Joe Premium Badge

Good to know! How long was your decant? And over how long a window did you enjoy it?
Jay Kline

Jay Kline Influencer Badge Premium Badge

@Vino Joe great questions; I have answers. Note updated!

Domaine du Pegau

Cuvée Réservé Châteauneuf-du-Pape Red Rhone Blend 2012

Popped and poured; enjoyed over the course of dinner. The 2012 Cuvée Réservée pours a deep ruby color with a slightly hazy, but mostly transparent core; medium+ viscosity with moderate staining of the tears. On the nose, the wine is developing with fabulous notes of ripe red and black bramble fruit: raspberries, Marionberries, licorice, red flowers, horse blanket, dried herbs, leather, and stony earth. On the palate, the wine is dry with medium+ tannin and medium acid. Confirming the notes from the nose. The finish is long and luscious. This is a very lovely Pegau that is squarely in its prime and strutting all of its stuff. Drink now through 2032. — 17 days ago

Shay, Lyle and 12 others liked this

Château d'Yquem

Sauternes Sémillon-Sauvignon Blanc Blend 2001

Without doubt the greatest sticky I’ve ever tasted. I nosed it for 30 mins, it was so clear and bright with tropical fruit and light stony minerality. The apricot and mango were lifted over my palate by actual angels who may’ve swiped a taste on the brief journey. Wish I could’ve sat up with a last glass all night, thank you Lenny. 🙏🏼 — a month ago

Daniel, Jeroen and 26 others liked this

Château Latour

Premier Grand Cru Classé Pauillac Red Bordeaux Blend 2011

Fantastic and seemed even more mature than 13 years. Dark dark but smooth and developed. It’s a focused wine in great balance. No complaints but you can tell it was a bit below the heights for Latour. Double decanted and enjoyed over 4+ hours. — 3 months ago

Tom, Bob and 21 others liked this
GaryWEdwards

GaryWEdwards

Nice report. Thank you!!

Château Léoville Barton

Saint-Julien Red Bordeaux Blend 1996

Opened and double-decanted several hours prior to service; enjoyed over the course of three hours. The 1996 pours a deep garnet color with a near opaque core. On the nose, the wine is developing and loaded with currants, pencil lead, earth and soft baking spices. On the palate, the wine is dry with medium+ tannin and medium+ acid. Confirming the notes from the nose. The finish is long and super grippy; slightly bitter and earthy. A lovely, classic expression of Bordeaux and drinking well in its prime. Drink now through 2046. — 4 days ago

Jakub, Tom and 11 others liked this
Severn Goodwin

Severn Goodwin Influencer Badge Premium Badge

You've been hitting all my favorite Léoville lately, so jealous
Jay Kline

Jay Kline Influencer Badge Premium Badge

@Severn Goodwin I catching up on some notes from a night with a line-up of bangers from Bordeaux. It was pretty awesome, ngl

Penfolds

Bin 389 South Australia Cabernet Shiraz

After opening up for just a few minutes- the initial lighter juiciness turns dark and smoky. Blackberries tempered by fig, carob, chestnut. Tannins are dry and bold. The acidity, which was barely noticeable with the first sips - builds over time and dominates the final finishing notes. — 13 days ago

Robert Indik
with Robert
Juan liked this

Domaine de la Romanée-Conti (DRC)

La Tâche Pinot Noir 2013

2013 vintage. Both excellent fill and cork. Decanted with infinitesimal sed. Slightly silvery color. Tasted after 1.5 and 2.5 hours open. Medium body. Nose slightly reticent during both tastes. Black tea and eucalyptus prominent first go round with both those still present but minimized second pass. Sprinkle in some cracked black pepper and white sage for round two and we have a winner. Finish lasted over a minute and the concentration was as expected given the decent street cred. No rush to crush but open waay early/decant this if enjoying in the next handful of years. 10.24.24. — 2 months ago

Ira, Bob and 24 others liked this