The Stump

Casella Wines

The Black Stump Durif Shiraz 2024

What’s Durif? Loved the combo with Australian Shiraz. Red and blackberry and cherry with a touch of oak and smoke. This was quite the fruit bomb with mild tannins and medium body. Please sir. . . I want some more. — 10 months ago

Schrader Cellars

Vieux- Os Old Vine Gnarly Stump Vineyard Zinfandel 2004

Slightly oxidize. Intriguing flavors. Really opened up in 30 minutes. Got spicy and and fill of zin.! Drink now — 5 years ago

Ira, Shay and 8 others liked this

d'Arenberg

The Stump Jump Sticky Adelaide Hills Chardonnay Blend 2010

2010. The honey and apple flavors in the wine paired great with a Sour Cream Raisin Pie for dessert! — 6 years ago

Josh and Allison liked this

Danila Pisano

Rossese di Dolceacqua 2017

Always good to stump even the most seasoned of blind tasters... — 6 years ago

romo, Keith and 8 others liked this
Tom Casagrande

Tom Casagrande Influencer Badge

Love a nice light Rossesse to wash down an Italian dinner every so often.

La Stoppa

Macchiona Dieciannidopo Emilia Red Blend 2007

This made for a real fun stump the chump wine. Lot going on here. — 9 years ago

Weingut Nik Weis

St. Urbans-Hof Leiwener Laurentiuslay Trockenbeerenauslese Riesling 1969

How to really stump someone in a blind tasting: 1) store a bottle of '69 Weis Leiwener Laurentiuslay Auslese in a box with lots of geuze for ages. 2) allow the wild yeast to enter the bottle and do its thing. 3) wait until you loose 1/4 of the wine through the cork as the pressure builds. 4) open under the table, with a serious 'pop' (to confuse the tasters). 5) serve this miraculously delicious sour 'petillant' (like a cross between a Belgian sour and a very good feinherbst) in riesling glasses. 6) bathe in the glorious confusion that ensues. — 9 years ago

Ted, Jonathan and 9 others liked this

Château Branaire (Duluc-Ducru)

St. Julien Red Bordeaux Blend 2006

Shay A
9.3

July's monthly WTF group meet up. Blind tasting with a theme of French wines. Bravo to all those who joined...great wines!

What a total stump by
@Andrew Heffley . The entire group guessed right bank Bordeaux. Did NOT expect left bank! Incredibly floral and fruity aromatically which seemed to line up with Merlot dominant wines. Felt like I got a hint of cab franc here too, which again would lean towards right bank Blends. Just goes to show you that when you think you know a french wine...
— 9 years ago

Andrew HeffleyJeff MeyerBill Makens
with Andrew, Jeff and 2 others
Dick, Mark and 43 others liked this
Somm David T

Somm David T Influencer Badge

Nice producer. St. Julian's are the softest wines on the Left Bank. It is one of characteristics of the terroir.
P A

P A

@Shay Aldriedge good for you great wine. Cheers 🍷

Lake's Folly

Hunter Valley Cabernets 2013

One doesn’t normally associate top flight Cabernet with the Hunter Valley but Lakes Folly , founded by ex surgeon Dr Max Lake (now past) turned that notion on its head and has been making top flight Cabernets for decades. This wine has strong mint aromas with some spice. Red fruited. Would stump a lot of tasters in a blind tasting as to its origins. If anyone can do Cabernets in the Hunter Valley it would be Lakes Folly. Had my last bottle on 4th October 2026 with no change to the notes. I still don’t believe that the Hunter Valley is a top terroir for Cabernets. I prefer Yarra Valley, Coonawarra or Margaret River. — a year ago

Ron, Tom and 16 others liked this
Ron R

Ron R Influencer Badge Premium Badge

I have a 98 mag that I purchased from the winery. I hope it still has some life in it…
Ceccherini Cristiano

Ceccherini Cristiano Influencer Badge

@Ron R it will be great, but pull the cork, open it🧐😉
Bob McDonald

Bob McDonald Influencer Badge Premium Badge

@Ron R Ron , I see the drinking window on the Winery website says drink to 2020 and 95 points. You should be right from Magnum but probably should open sooner rather than later. I’m sure it will be excellent.

Tasca D'Almerita

Rosso del Conte Contea di Sclafani Red Blend 2008

Presented double-blind. Deep ruby color with a slightly watery rim; medium viscosity. No signs of particles or gas. On the nose, dark fruits, plums, cassis, some bell pepper, dry leaf tobacco, earth and some baking spice indicating the use of some barrique, probably French oak. On the palate, creme de cassis, some gravely earth, and baking spices. Medium plus tannin, medium plus acid. This is a very elegant wine. Beautiful, long, gorgeous finish. Likely a Cabernet Sauvignon-based blend. The wine was balanced and leaning more towards its structure which took me to the Old World, most likely left bank Bordeaux. Given the characteristics, I was thinking Margaux specifically. So that was my call...likely with 20+ years of age since it seems the tannins were integrating quite nicely. Turns out I got the variety and the Old World part right 😅. What a wine! I didn’t know folks were making stuff like this in Sicilia. This could stump anyone without any prior experience. Killer QPR even at $50. — 6 years ago

Peter, Daniel P. and 7 others liked this

d'Arenberg

The Custodian McLaren Vale Grenache 2016

I really love D’Arenberg. Their budget wines- Stump Jumps - are always a good value( though not quite as good the last few years. This one and the Shiraz ( The Footbolt) are always terrific and @20$ I cant really afford the expensive ones but these rock. Medium bodied- not big and jammy- but great fruit and no wood! Finish lingers with some tannic bitterness. Can drink on its own or very food friendly. I had it with grilled burgers. And vintage to vintage, it’s really good! — 6 years ago

Severn, Dawn and 6 others liked this

Casella Wines

Beyond The Black Stump Shiraz 2015

Good stuff. Look for in state store. — 9 years ago

Domaine Bernard Defaix

Saint Bris Sauvignon

wine 🍷 is a process of endless discovery: here I always thought white #wine from Burgundy could only be from the Chardonnay and Aligoté grapes, and along comes this pretty "#SaintBris", located southwest of #Chablis and powered by the very unBurgundian Sauvignon Blanc. This Bernard Defaix is medium weight, citrusy, with just the right about of "green" and crispness. Find it and you will stump the most knowledgable Burghounds. #Burgundy 🇫🇷

— 9 years ago

Damiani Wine Cellars

Vino Rosso Finger Lakes Marechal Foch

A tasty Non Vintage, Foch and Franc blend red wine from the Finger Lakes that is supple on the palate, inky and fruit driven with some leather. Talk about a wine to stump people in a blind tasting.... — 9 years ago

Chris liked this

Quinta do Pôpa

Douro White Blend 2019

93 yo old vines. Orange wine light (36 hours on skins), 🦶 stump, granite tanks, 6 mo in french oak, more structure, 10.5% abv, €29.9 — 2 years ago

Domaine Sorin-Coquard

Cuvee Antique Cesar 2019

As someone else noted, a rare bottle of a super rare red grape from Burgundy called “Cesar” (10 hectares in the world) — very dark color, rich, dark fruits, some noticeable structure, this needs 3-5 years aging to settle down, a great “stump your wine friends” wine!! — 3 years ago

Jim Powers
with Jim
Aravind, Jan and 4 others liked this
Aravind A

Aravind A Premium Badge

@Doug Powers this is a fun btl! Nice pull!

Fanagoria

100 Shades Saperavi 2013

Terrific tenderness of close maturity! Elegant, silky, inspiring, soft, gorgeous representative of the style!
100%Saperavi harvested from best plots with controlled yield. Vinified with pigeage. MLF on pulp. Aged 1yr in Caucasian oak.

Dark cherry red, (pale) crimson rim.
Seducing bouquet of purple lilac, violets, huckleberry juice, campfire, prune, light whiff of barnyard, pine forest, blackberry, smoked tkemali plum, leather boots, hibiscus broth, old wood stump, peat, laurel, whiff of gore, black cherry jam, tobacco leaf, basil, curd, iodine, pome churchkhela, cinnamon pie, dried lavender, cappuccino.
Extremely rounded, silky and super-friendly palate. Medium(+) body, perfectly integrated acidity, gentle/polished tannins. Black gooseberry, blackberry, warm oak, blueberry, tobacco, earth, black currant jam, chokeberry jam, touch of milky chocolate.
Smoothly obducing and persistent finish of dried raspberry, black cherry, black currant jam, mocha and some gentle spices.
Paired fillet minion as well as lamb shovel baked with herbs.
93/100
— 6 years ago

Joshua and Julia liked this

Ridge Vineyards

Estate Monte Bello Vineyard Merlot 2012

Would have been a nice Merlot in the cab vs Merlot tasting. The good? This is a merlot. The bad? If you're trying to stump someone? Good luck because....this is a classic merlot. From Monte Bello Vineyard. Nose is brambly, yet a bit sweet. Terroir is on the nose in full force. The entry is dark yet a slight bit youthful. Forest floor, plum, black fruit and quite a bit of it. Finishes with some drier tannin. This one is at the top of its game right now, but isn't going to win many awards for WOTN as it just isn't complex on its own. Drank MUCH better with food. Drink or hold another 5 to 10 years. — 8 years ago

Paul, Neil and 20 others liked this
Neil Valenzuela

Neil Valenzuela

❤️Ridge, Cupertino

Domaine Drouhin-Laroze

Latricières-Chambertin Pinot Noir 1971

An intoxicating nose of coffee-mushroom-bacon-sandwich discovered inside a half-rotted moss covered stump in the deepest of woods. Need we say more? Amazingly well-preserved. — 9 years ago

Ira liked this

Casella Wines

Reserve The Black Stump Clare Valley Shiraz

Superb full bodied wine great with steak — 9 years ago