Ira Schwartz

9.5

The nose alone is a 10. Like being locked in a flower shop and all of the flowers fell on your face and when you stood up James Cagney smashed a grapefruit in your face. So much going on in the mouth , citrus, spice and stone fruits. The acid provides you with a very long and rounded finish.. — a month ago

Paul Masson

9.0

Easygoing — 9 months ago

Aaron Tan

9.3

Merry Christmas to all on Delectable! The best drop during our wine squad’s pre-Christmas gathering has to be this masterpiece from Tim Frohlich. Such insane concentration, yet so filigreed and focused. The trademark reduction and vintage's ripeness gave it such an intense jackfruit character. Notes of herbs, spices, and ripe oranges too, as well as hints of mint and white florals. The palate was dense, silky, and straight up powerful, but never heavy - it remained juicy, bright, and saline throughout. And the finish here was just something else. It went on and on, filled with zingy citrus and a smoky, stony minerality. Really impressive stuff here and definitely a worthy contender (vs. Felseneck) for the title of Schafer-Frohlich’s top wine. — 2 years ago

Matthew Cohen

9.6

Nose: intense white and yellow flowers. Expansive. Hints of grapefruit peel. Complex. An element of aged profundity.

Palate: the wall of flavor. Mineral. Citrus. Dense. Elegant. Grippy. A minor hint of slutty sexiness. Grapefruit.

Long. — 2 months ago

Jeroen Koenen

9.3

APnr 21-08; Felseneck goldcap spatlese.
Youthful, fresh, generous. Beautiful fruit, citrus and peach, lovely acidity and salinity. Over 18 years old, this wine possesses an impressive clarity, lightness, and a long gentle finish. — 3 months ago

Ron Siegel

9.2

This had notes of citrus, orchid fruit, honey, floral with vibrant acidity — 10 months ago

Tree Kilpatrick

9.1

Older vintage. Lighter and whiter. Smells great. Apples and citrus. Hint of rocks. Flavors are easy, smooth and luscious. Creamy. This is a lovely white. Complex, clean and lovely. — 4 years ago

Pinotman /// Andreas

9.7

85$/12.5%. Sadly 85$. I met Tim Fröhlich (aka Tim ‘Cheerful’) ca. 15 years??? ago at ‘La République’ in LA - now a restaurant - in what used to be the house of Charlie Chaplin. It was a major Riesling tasting with the late Rudi Wiest. Anyways ever since I have been a mega fan. White peach, white flowers on the nose. Smokey and wild in the glass. Yeasty. Hint sweetness nicely balanced with acidity. Stonefruit, white peach, yellow peach, hint sour mandarine, elderberry. Incredible minerality - bursting with freshness and vitality and Fröhlichness - its good to be alive! — 3 months ago

Lyle Fass

Founder Fass Selections

9.6

Concentrated, deep, nimble and painfully young. Needs 5-6 years. — 6 months ago

Jakub Kalinowski

8.9

A bit closed & ‘soapy’ on opening, after 1h opens up showing juicy pear, yellow apple and some peach. Some rye toast, a bit is stony minerality. Fresh & nice.
On the palate this has nice depth, impeccable balance, purity of fruit and a salty, spicy, mineral finish of remarkable length.
Perfect as an aperitif but would hold its weight with food. a nice one. — 2 years ago